Polk County can send a message to Madison on November 4 that affordable health care for all must be a priority NOW! Cast your "Yes" Vote on the Health Care Referendum.
The Referendum does not specify exactly which health care plan should be adopted. The Referendum simply tells our legislature that health care must be their number 1 priority, and that they should get to work immediately to find a way to provide affordable health care for Wisconsin residents.
.
Monday, October 20, 2008
Friday, October 10, 2008
Economic Impact of Golden Age Manor: the Rest of the Story, JoAnn Hallquist
The Ledger’s October 2nd edition reports Golden Age Manor losses at $8.1 million over the last 10 years. Sorry, but this isn’t the correct number to focus on. The losses over the last 10 years totaled $2.4 million. Why the difference?
The federal government pays the government-owned nursing homes, not just Golden Age Manor, to stay in business through a program known as the Intergovernmental Transfer Program (now called Supplemental Payments Program). Those federal funds enter Polk County to help pay our county nursing home, Golden Age Manor, for the extra costs associated with a high percentage of Medicaid residents – costs that are above and beyond the inadequate reimbursement under the Medicaid program. Those funds have totaled $5.5 million over the last 10 years.
Everything was fine as long as Golden Age Manor made a profit and contributed to the county coffers. The problem of the last ten years is that the County Board members see losses on the balance sheet – the County has transferred $2.1 million ($207,040 annual average) to Golden Age over the past 10 years. If the projections are accurate, Golden Age will realize a profit for 2008 due to numerous factors including a change in billing by a new therapy contractor.
A key question: what happens if the Golden Age Manor becomes a private nursing home? The number one responsibility of the private owner is to make a profit for its owners. To accomplish this at Golden Age Manor, there will be many difficult decisions such as to reduce costs and/or change the revenue sources. Based on what happens in other private nursing homes, they could cut employee wages and benefits or reduce the number of Medicaid patients. The Alzheimer’s unit could be converted to another use because of the high cost of operation.
No federal funds will be available to cover the extra costs no longer being reimbursed. I repeat that the federal funds will no longer be available to the Polk County economy if a private nursing home replaces Golden Age. The federal funds create a significant economic impact in Polk County - an annual average of $547,207 over the last 10 years. Those funds pay for wages, benefits, supplies and other purchases; those purchases are turned over in the economy because the stores where the money is spent benefit, and they in turn are able to employ more people, make more purchases. That is the economic multiplier theory but it is real in Polk County. I am still checking how many times that money turns over in our economy but it is anywhere from 2 to 4 times and possibly higher. Some of those sales are subject to the half percent sales tax and contribute to Polk County revenue. Golden Age employees live in many locations in the County so the impact is not confined to the southeastern part of the county.
There is an additional revenue loss that occurs in this way: If all five nursing homes – all privately owned – turn away a Medicaid patient because they can’t provide the services, the County is liable under Wisconsin State Statutes (Chapter 51.42) for treating them at other out-of-county facilities that are equipped to accept them. Those facilities charge $740 per day and more. Polk County has to pick up the tab under the Human Services budget. If one person can’t be handled in a county facility, then the average annual loss of $207,040 would be exhausted in 279 patient days.
The County engaged in strategic planning last year and probably all County Board members would agree that the County needs to pursue economic development projects. Yet, it forgot that objective in trying to transfer the Golden Age Manor to private hands.
It is not easy to estimate the full economic impact of a sale but it is clear that the county transfers to cover past losses do not tell the full story.
JoAnn Hallquist
715-268-6134
Town of Lincoln
The federal government pays the government-owned nursing homes, not just Golden Age Manor, to stay in business through a program known as the Intergovernmental Transfer Program (now called Supplemental Payments Program). Those federal funds enter Polk County to help pay our county nursing home, Golden Age Manor, for the extra costs associated with a high percentage of Medicaid residents – costs that are above and beyond the inadequate reimbursement under the Medicaid program. Those funds have totaled $5.5 million over the last 10 years.
Everything was fine as long as Golden Age Manor made a profit and contributed to the county coffers. The problem of the last ten years is that the County Board members see losses on the balance sheet – the County has transferred $2.1 million ($207,040 annual average) to Golden Age over the past 10 years. If the projections are accurate, Golden Age will realize a profit for 2008 due to numerous factors including a change in billing by a new therapy contractor.
A key question: what happens if the Golden Age Manor becomes a private nursing home? The number one responsibility of the private owner is to make a profit for its owners. To accomplish this at Golden Age Manor, there will be many difficult decisions such as to reduce costs and/or change the revenue sources. Based on what happens in other private nursing homes, they could cut employee wages and benefits or reduce the number of Medicaid patients. The Alzheimer’s unit could be converted to another use because of the high cost of operation.
No federal funds will be available to cover the extra costs no longer being reimbursed. I repeat that the federal funds will no longer be available to the Polk County economy if a private nursing home replaces Golden Age. The federal funds create a significant economic impact in Polk County - an annual average of $547,207 over the last 10 years. Those funds pay for wages, benefits, supplies and other purchases; those purchases are turned over in the economy because the stores where the money is spent benefit, and they in turn are able to employ more people, make more purchases. That is the economic multiplier theory but it is real in Polk County. I am still checking how many times that money turns over in our economy but it is anywhere from 2 to 4 times and possibly higher. Some of those sales are subject to the half percent sales tax and contribute to Polk County revenue. Golden Age employees live in many locations in the County so the impact is not confined to the southeastern part of the county.
There is an additional revenue loss that occurs in this way: If all five nursing homes – all privately owned – turn away a Medicaid patient because they can’t provide the services, the County is liable under Wisconsin State Statutes (Chapter 51.42) for treating them at other out-of-county facilities that are equipped to accept them. Those facilities charge $740 per day and more. Polk County has to pick up the tab under the Human Services budget. If one person can’t be handled in a county facility, then the average annual loss of $207,040 would be exhausted in 279 patient days.
The County engaged in strategic planning last year and probably all County Board members would agree that the County needs to pursue economic development projects. Yet, it forgot that objective in trying to transfer the Golden Age Manor to private hands.
It is not easy to estimate the full economic impact of a sale but it is clear that the county transfers to cover past losses do not tell the full story.
JoAnn Hallquist
715-268-6134
Town of Lincoln
Sunday, September 21, 2008
What Next in the GAM Saga?
The upcoming September 30 Board Meeting will address the GAM situation, which is turning out to be a total fiasco for the County. It's too bad, because the money Polk County has blown on legal fees would have gone a long way toward running the facility. Nevertheless, it is what it is, and we have to move forward from here.
My feeling is that the deal that was struck with Rice Properties was a sweetheart arrangement for Rice Properties. It was never in the best interests of the County, the residents, or the employees of the Golden Age Manor.
As our population ages, the services offered by the Golden Age Manor become increasingly important.
If Rice Properties could operate the Golden Age Manor at a profit, is there any reason why Polk County cannot operate the facility to break even? We don't expect the nursing home to turn a profit and help reduce our taxes, do we? We don't expect the Sheriff's Department to show a profit, or the Highway Department.
When Jim Drabek, a concerned citizen, brought the matter of the deed restriction to the attention of the County Board, he was treated disrespectfully and essentially ignored. I guess Mr. Drabek got the last laugh with the Appellate Court decision last week.
Gene Sollman also deserves credit for hanging in there in the face of some pretty vocal opposition on the Golden Age Manor Board. He did the right thing for Polk County.
My feeling is that the deal that was struck with Rice Properties was a sweetheart arrangement for Rice Properties. It was never in the best interests of the County, the residents, or the employees of the Golden Age Manor.
As our population ages, the services offered by the Golden Age Manor become increasingly important.
If Rice Properties could operate the Golden Age Manor at a profit, is there any reason why Polk County cannot operate the facility to break even? We don't expect the nursing home to turn a profit and help reduce our taxes, do we? We don't expect the Sheriff's Department to show a profit, or the Highway Department.
When Jim Drabek, a concerned citizen, brought the matter of the deed restriction to the attention of the County Board, he was treated disrespectfully and essentially ignored. I guess Mr. Drabek got the last laugh with the Appellate Court decision last week.
Gene Sollman also deserves credit for hanging in there in the face of some pretty vocal opposition on the Golden Age Manor Board. He did the right thing for Polk County.
Saturday, September 20, 2008
Amery-Dresser Trail Becomes a Reality
After years of negotiation, litigation, hearings, planning and delay, it was amazing how quickly a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) was approved by the Polk County Board that created the Amery-Dresser Trail.
Debbie Peterson, the head of the Parks and Recreation Department, assured the Board that no money from the County levy will be used to operate, repair or maintain the trail. The source of funds for trail development will be grants and other contributions from business and private sponsors. The DNR will take care of initial clearing and grading the trail for foot traffic. The MOA contemplates further improvements so the trail can be used for bicycling, provided grant money is obtained for that purpose.
My hope is that the Property Committee will keep its promise to "work co-operatively" on the Amery-Dresser Trail issue. Some members of the Property Committee may prefer to delay development of the Trail for non-motorized use, in hopes that State law will change to permit motorized uses on State Trails. We'll be keeping an eye on this.
The Amery-Dresser Trail is located within 60 miles of the Metropolitan Twin Cities, a major population center. The tourist dollars that a bike trail will bring into our area are significant. Business will benefit, and new businesses will appear. There is plenty of evidence to support this statement. Just look at similar developments in Menomonie, Wisconsin, and Lanesboro, Minnesota, where "Rails-to-Trails" just like the Amery-Dresser Trail have benefited their respective communities and the surrounding areas.
The benefit goes beyond economic. There are public health benefits, too. People will be able to get out and exercise on a safe trail separate from high-speed traffic on County Roads, particularly County Road F near Amery. Some folks will bike to work on the trail. Kids willl be able to bike safely to see friends or to go to school.
Recent surveys show that living on a bike path is second only to lakeshore property in popularity. Property values along the Trail will improve with development of the Amery-Dresser Trail.
This will be a gem that will make Polk County proud for generations.
Debbie Peterson, the head of the Parks and Recreation Department, assured the Board that no money from the County levy will be used to operate, repair or maintain the trail. The source of funds for trail development will be grants and other contributions from business and private sponsors. The DNR will take care of initial clearing and grading the trail for foot traffic. The MOA contemplates further improvements so the trail can be used for bicycling, provided grant money is obtained for that purpose.
My hope is that the Property Committee will keep its promise to "work co-operatively" on the Amery-Dresser Trail issue. Some members of the Property Committee may prefer to delay development of the Trail for non-motorized use, in hopes that State law will change to permit motorized uses on State Trails. We'll be keeping an eye on this.
The Amery-Dresser Trail is located within 60 miles of the Metropolitan Twin Cities, a major population center. The tourist dollars that a bike trail will bring into our area are significant. Business will benefit, and new businesses will appear. There is plenty of evidence to support this statement. Just look at similar developments in Menomonie, Wisconsin, and Lanesboro, Minnesota, where "Rails-to-Trails" just like the Amery-Dresser Trail have benefited their respective communities and the surrounding areas.
The benefit goes beyond economic. There are public health benefits, too. People will be able to get out and exercise on a safe trail separate from high-speed traffic on County Roads, particularly County Road F near Amery. Some folks will bike to work on the trail. Kids willl be able to bike safely to see friends or to go to school.
Recent surveys show that living on a bike path is second only to lakeshore property in popularity. Property values along the Trail will improve with development of the Amery-Dresser Trail.
This will be a gem that will make Polk County proud for generations.
Saturday, August 23, 2008
Samantha's Here!
Our new grand-daughter, Samantha Liu Stoneking, arrived on August 20 at 2:30 a.m. She's a beauty, 7 pounds 5 ounces and 19 3/8 inches "tall". Mom and baby are doing fine. They're coming home today.
Saturday, July 19, 2008
Polk County Tourism
Promoting tourism in Polk County makes terrific economic sense. Why? Because, by definition, money spent by tourists from outside Polk County is money brought into the local economy from outside. With the rising price of gasoline a tourist destination that is close in proximity to a major population center, and boasts the striking natural beauty that Polk County offers, is a natural draw for those tourist dollars.
Some think that only hotels and restaurants benefit from increased tourism. This ignores the fact that a dollar spent at a restaurant is spent again by the waitstaff or restaurant owner (most often a county resident) and most often in a local business. This same dollar is then spent again and again in the local economy. Furthermore, tourists spend at businesses other than motels and restaurants. I think it's safe to say that vacationers spend more freely than people who stay at home. We save up for vacations so we can spend more on attractions and recreation.
But the major point is that these are NEW dollars injected into the economy, not recycled money from our own pockets.
The folks staffing the Polk County Information Center, which is ideally located just across the U. S. 8 bridge, field more than tourism-related questions. The Center is entering its 15th year of operation.
Many inquiries concern re-locating businesses to Polk County, where to cast votes in elections, where to pay taxes, information concerning recycling programs, as well as Sheriff's Department and other aspects of Polk County Government.
In June, 2008, the Center had a total of 8619 contacts, including 1872 e-mail requests for information, 2216 "hits" on its web site, 1008 telephone requests for information, 3472 entries in the visitor's book, and 4 "snail mail" requests for information (proving that there are still people using the U. S. Mail!) The Center provides the Polk County Visitor's Guide, County and State Maps, State and Federal Parks information packets, information about local churches, fishing/hunting regulations and maps, snowmobile and ATV maps, biking and hiking guides, resort guides, campground locations, motel and Bed & Breakfast maps, restaurant guides and information about local real estate. And this is only a partial list.
The advertising obtained by the staff at the Polk County Information Center is priceless. Through their close relationships with the Wisconsin Department of Tourism, Minnesota Monthly, Wisconsin Trails, AAA, Twin Cities and area newspapers, television and radio stations and travel shows, the staff works tirelessly to keep Polk County "on the radar" for potential tourism and economic development. For more information, contact the Center at www.polkinfo@charterinternet.net or check out the Center's web site at www.polkcountytourism.com.
Here's the bottom line: According to State of Wisconsin figures, tourists spent an estimated $75.3 million in Polk County in 2007. Tourist dollars supported 1,810 full-time equivalent jobs in the county.
For the benefit received through the Polk County Information Center's efforts, taxpayers pay $95,000. Not a bad return on investment.
Cutting funding for the Polk County Information Center would be nothing short of killing the fabled "Goose that lays golden eggs." Very short-sighted...
Some think that only hotels and restaurants benefit from increased tourism. This ignores the fact that a dollar spent at a restaurant is spent again by the waitstaff or restaurant owner (most often a county resident) and most often in a local business. This same dollar is then spent again and again in the local economy. Furthermore, tourists spend at businesses other than motels and restaurants. I think it's safe to say that vacationers spend more freely than people who stay at home. We save up for vacations so we can spend more on attractions and recreation.
But the major point is that these are NEW dollars injected into the economy, not recycled money from our own pockets.
The folks staffing the Polk County Information Center, which is ideally located just across the U. S. 8 bridge, field more than tourism-related questions. The Center is entering its 15th year of operation.
Many inquiries concern re-locating businesses to Polk County, where to cast votes in elections, where to pay taxes, information concerning recycling programs, as well as Sheriff's Department and other aspects of Polk County Government.
In June, 2008, the Center had a total of 8619 contacts, including 1872 e-mail requests for information, 2216 "hits" on its web site, 1008 telephone requests for information, 3472 entries in the visitor's book, and 4 "snail mail" requests for information (proving that there are still people using the U. S. Mail!) The Center provides the Polk County Visitor's Guide, County and State Maps, State and Federal Parks information packets, information about local churches, fishing/hunting regulations and maps, snowmobile and ATV maps, biking and hiking guides, resort guides, campground locations, motel and Bed & Breakfast maps, restaurant guides and information about local real estate. And this is only a partial list.
The advertising obtained by the staff at the Polk County Information Center is priceless. Through their close relationships with the Wisconsin Department of Tourism, Minnesota Monthly, Wisconsin Trails, AAA, Twin Cities and area newspapers, television and radio stations and travel shows, the staff works tirelessly to keep Polk County "on the radar" for potential tourism and economic development. For more information, contact the Center at www.polkinfo@charterinternet.net or check out the Center's web site at www.polkcountytourism.com.
Here's the bottom line: According to State of Wisconsin figures, tourists spent an estimated $75.3 million in Polk County in 2007. Tourist dollars supported 1,810 full-time equivalent jobs in the county.
For the benefit received through the Polk County Information Center's efforts, taxpayers pay $95,000. Not a bad return on investment.
Cutting funding for the Polk County Information Center would be nothing short of killing the fabled "Goose that lays golden eggs." Very short-sighted...
Thursday, July 17, 2008
Jeff Peterson's Appointment to the BOA
At the June meeting of the Polk County Board of Supervisors, Chair Bryan Beseler appointed Jeff Peterson to the Board of Adjustment. Other people were also appointed at the June meeting to other positions on various committees. The Board voted at the June meeting to confirm Peterson's appointment to the BOA. This month, part of Agenda item XIV, labeled "Appointments", was a "Motion for Reconsideration of June 2008 Appointments". No written motion signed by a supervisor accompanied the agenda, so it was unclear exactly which member of the Board of Supervisors was the one making the motion. In any event, when the item came before the Board of Supervisors for discussion, it quickly became obvious that the intent of the motion was to remove newly-appointed member of the Board of Adjustment Jeff Peterson.
Local builder Chris Nelson urged the Board of Supervisors to remove Peterson from the BOA. Randy Freer, who happens to be Supervisor Brown's brother-in-law, also spoke in favor of removing Peterson. Two other individuals, Messrs. Jensen and Hibbs, asked that Peterson be replaced. One of these gentleman commented that Peterson had been replaced on the County Board and was no longer his Supervisor, apparently reasoning that Peterson, having lost the election to Supervisor Brown, should no longer be involved in County business.
Mr. Nelson's opposition to Peterson's appointment appears to come from Mr. Nelson's perception that Peterson will be too strict in his interpretation of the ordinances the Board of Adjustment is charged to interpret and apply. As near as I could tell, the remaining speakers simply desired to have someone else appointed to the position without stating any reason why Peterson was unacceptable.
Land and Water director Tim Ritten told me in June that he had assured Mr. Nelson that Peterson would be reasonable to work with, and would apply the law properly and without favor or prejudice. Mr. Nelson was not convinced.
When it came time to vote, four Supervisors voted to reconsider the Peterson appointment to the BOA: Joan Peterson, Herschel Brown, James Edgell and Brian Masters. Nineteen Supervisors voted against reconsidering the appointment.
There are several reasons why motions to reconsider Board decisions should not be taken lightly. How much of the County's business can get done if Board time is consumed with re-thinking decisions made only thirty days earlier? When does a decision ever become final? On that grounds alone, the Board was wise to decline the motion to reconsider Peterson's appointment to the Board of Adjustment.
But there is a better, far more compelling, reason to leave Peterson on the BOA: Peterson will do a fine job in that position. Those of us who served with Jeff on the Polk County Board of Supervisors know that he is intelligent, committed to the environment, and fair-minded. He'll listen to applicants and apply the law evenly. The BOA has had some trouble in the past with claims that it failed to follow its own procedures and guidelines in making decisions. That's not likely to happen again with Peterson serving on the BOA.
Local builder Chris Nelson urged the Board of Supervisors to remove Peterson from the BOA. Randy Freer, who happens to be Supervisor Brown's brother-in-law, also spoke in favor of removing Peterson. Two other individuals, Messrs. Jensen and Hibbs, asked that Peterson be replaced. One of these gentleman commented that Peterson had been replaced on the County Board and was no longer his Supervisor, apparently reasoning that Peterson, having lost the election to Supervisor Brown, should no longer be involved in County business.
Mr. Nelson's opposition to Peterson's appointment appears to come from Mr. Nelson's perception that Peterson will be too strict in his interpretation of the ordinances the Board of Adjustment is charged to interpret and apply. As near as I could tell, the remaining speakers simply desired to have someone else appointed to the position without stating any reason why Peterson was unacceptable.
Land and Water director Tim Ritten told me in June that he had assured Mr. Nelson that Peterson would be reasonable to work with, and would apply the law properly and without favor or prejudice. Mr. Nelson was not convinced.
When it came time to vote, four Supervisors voted to reconsider the Peterson appointment to the BOA: Joan Peterson, Herschel Brown, James Edgell and Brian Masters. Nineteen Supervisors voted against reconsidering the appointment.
There are several reasons why motions to reconsider Board decisions should not be taken lightly. How much of the County's business can get done if Board time is consumed with re-thinking decisions made only thirty days earlier? When does a decision ever become final? On that grounds alone, the Board was wise to decline the motion to reconsider Peterson's appointment to the Board of Adjustment.
But there is a better, far more compelling, reason to leave Peterson on the BOA: Peterson will do a fine job in that position. Those of us who served with Jeff on the Polk County Board of Supervisors know that he is intelligent, committed to the environment, and fair-minded. He'll listen to applicants and apply the law evenly. The BOA has had some trouble in the past with claims that it failed to follow its own procedures and guidelines in making decisions. That's not likely to happen again with Peterson serving on the BOA.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)